Loading
This thread is archived and the information may not be up-to-date. You can't reply to this thread.
DLS(Initiate)Initiate
5 Apr 2023

What is considered "holding an interest" in property with regards to eligibility for first home super saver?


In the following scenario:

  • Property was held in family trust with newly established corporate trustee
  • Trust deed schedule identified Specified Beneficiaries.
  • Trust deed clauses identified that siblings of Specified Beneficiaries, are also beneficiaries.
  • The Specified Beneficiaries were founding directors and shareholders of the corporate trustee. They were also guarantors on the property loan.
  • The sibling was later added as a director and shareholder of the corporate trustee. Was never a loan guarantor.
  • The Specified Beneficiaries and sibling lived in the property.


Main Question: Is the sibling considered to "hold an interest in property" and therefore be ineligible for FHSS?


Sub Question: Are the Specified Beneficiaries considered to "hold an interest in property"? and therefore be ineligible for FHSS?


Thanks!

1,156 views
5 replies
1,156 views
5 replies

Most helpful response

Most helpful reply

AriATO(Community Support)Community Support
13 Apr 2023

Hi @DLS


Our FHSS area is still checking a few things for this one. We'll be in touch again soon.

All replies

AriATO(Community Support)Community Support
21 Apr 2023

Hi @DLS


Sorry we haven't got back to you yet.


The trust makes this a bit more complex and we need a bit more time.

DLS(Initiate)Initiate
3 May 2023

Hi


Just checking in on this. It’s been marked as answered, but I can only see responses for future follow up.


Thank you

ATO Certified Response
AriATO(Community Support)Community Support
ATO Certified Response4 May 2023

Hi DLS,


Thanks for waiting.


For FHSS purposes, our view is that an “interest in property” includes any type of interest in real property. This means that ‘freehold interest’ includes both legal and equitable interests. Whether the specified beneficiary or their sibling holds an interest in the property will depend on the terms of the trust deed. 


If an individual is the beneficiary of a trust and the trustee of which holds or has held real property. Then it's necessary to consider whether the beneficiary also holds or has held real property an equitable right in that real property. That gives rise to an interest set out in the FHSS Scheme law that would make them ineligible to utilise the scheme.  


The nature of a beneficiary’s interest in trust property must be determined under the terms of the particular trust. For example, the terms of a trust deed may only provide a beneficiary an interest in the income of the trust. In the case of a discretionary trust. A beneficiary will ordinarily only have an interest that amounts to ensuring the proper administration of the trust by the trustee. The nature of these interests and rights will not give the beneficiary a proprietary interest in the underlying property held by the trust estate. In contrast, the trust deed may expressly provide that a beneficiary of the trust has an interest in specific assets of the trust, or the entirety of the trust assets. 


Have a look at our FHSSS Essentials guide we've put together. Under the heading ‘Am I eligible’ you'll find handy info about eligibility and a link to GN 2018/1 which has some common scenarios.

If you need more specific advice around the FHSSS eligibility requirements you can contact us for tailored technical assistance

Loading
Definition of "holding an interest" in property with regards to first home super saver scheme | ATO Community