Dear ATO Community,
A French tax resident (Australian tax non-resident) in France, makes personal deductible concessional contributions from pre-tax income (ITAA1997 s290-15) to an Australian super fund. The fund withholds 15% contributions tax (s295-165) per NOI notice.
French tax authorities have limited experience with Australian superannuation. If DTA confirms these contributions are not assessable income, French reporting becomes straightforward - Form 2047 transfer notation only, with no additional tax liability since pre-tax income was already declared in France.
Could the ATO Community please provide **clear "yes/no" answers with DTA references or cases?
## Scenario 1: Funded by Australian-Source Pre-Tax Income
1. Does Australia treat personal deductible concessional contributions from Australian-source pre-tax income as assessable income of the French tax resident?
2. If Australia does not treat these contributions as assessable income, how should France treat them under DTA Article 23 (tax credit mechanism)?
## Scenario 2: Funded by Third-Country Source Pre-Tax Income (neither Australia nor France)
3. Does Australia treat personal deductible concessional contributions from third-country source pre-tax income as assessable income of the French tax resident?
4. If Australia does not treat these contributions as assessable income, does French CGI Article 4A impose a declaration obligation?
## Scenario 3: Funded by French-Source Pre-Tax Income
5. Does Australia treat personal deductible concessional contributions from French-source pre-tax income as assessable income of the French tax resident?
6. If Australia does not treat these contributions as assessable income, does DTA Article 23 allow credit for the 15% Australian contributions tax in France?
## Tax Credit Question (Critical for French Reporting)
7. If France treats these contributions as taxable income requiring declaration, can the 15% Australian contributions tax (withheld by super fund per NOI) be claimed as a foreign tax credit in France under DTA Article 23?