I have a specific question on whether certain supports funded by NDIS attract GST.
Community access supports (Core category 4 – Assistance with Social, Economic and Community Participation) for an individual (not in a group or residential care facility) that is not specifically skills building. It might be purely social or recreational, e.g.: going to the cinema, a concert, or support to visit family.
I will take you through my pathway of understanding.
Firstly I reviewed this page:
Assuming that the service meets the first three criteria:
- the NDIS participant has a NDIS plan in effect
- the supply is of reasonable and necessary supports that are specified in the statement of supports in the participant's NDIS plan
- there is a written agreement between you and the NDIS participant (or another person)
Then it comes down to whether:
- it is a supply covered by one of the tables in the A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) (GST free Supply—National Disability Insurance Scheme Supports) Determination 2021 (NDIS Determination).
We then determine that the service is clearly NOT listed in Table 1.
We then need to determine if Table 2 applies, however it isn't absolutely clear even after reading the explanatory statement.
Item 1 "Assistance with daily personal activities" in Table 2 is only covering NDIS Core Category 1, not category 4 (Social and Community participation).
Item 2 on Table 2 " Specialised assessment and development of daily living and life skills, including community participation" is most relevant.
But the NDIS 2021/1 - Explanatory statement indicates that it wouldn't apply unless it was:
- for "training or skills development", OR
- in a group, OR
- in a centre based program, OR
- for a person in a residential care facility
There does not appear to be an allowance for an individual to receive support to access the community purely for a social or recreational pursuit, such as going to the cinema, out to a cafe for a meal, or even being accompanied for a walk through the park.
Even if we can agree that Item 2 in Table 2 is applicable somehow, then we also need to consider which Determination applies.
- The Care Determination is the most likely candidate
- We can rule out the Residential Care Determination
- We can also rule out the Health Services Determination
- Is there another determination?
So, we look at the Care Determination and find that the service is NOT listed in Schedule 1
It could 'possibly' be described as "Respite Care" or "Day Care" but we generally refer to respite as 'Short term Accommodation' being a support for 24hrs or longer and 'day care' is usually within a group facility. These two services are not regarded as being the same as 1:1 community access support for the purposes of this enquiry.
Is there a definition of 'respite' or 'day care' that would allow us to use this Schedule?
Our final step …
If Table 2, Item 2 is correct (somehow), and we can agree that the service is listed in Schedule 1 of the Care Determination, then it would still need to meet the definition of a 'Targeted Person', including clause 3(c) of the Care Determination, namely:
(c) would, in the absence of services of the kind mentioned in Schedule 1, be at risk of prematurely or inappropriately needing:
(i) long term care in a hospital or other institution; or
(ii) residential care within the meaning of the Aged Care Act 1997.
It is a very unlikely and problematic conclusion that a person would prematurely or inappropriately need long term hospital or residential care if they did not have support to go to the cinema (as an example).
Is there another determination that answers this question?
Is this an oversight in the tax law?
Are service providers required to charge GST for social and community access support to an individual that does not meet the complex criteria listed above?
These questions have significant ramifications for the entire NDIS sector as up to 16% of NDIS funding is allocated for social and community access. That is more than $4 billion a year. which means up to $400 million in lost GST revenue for the ATO. Admittedly it will be much less than that.
The other issue is compliance as service providers would need to consider the personal circumstances of each participant before determining whether GST needed to be charged or not. That is quite literally a bureaucratic nightmare.
In the absence of a determination or ruling on this matter the problem is very real for hundreds of thousands of service providers.
I thank you for your time in advance of your much welcomed response.