Loading
Plantatree(Champion)Champion
28 Aug 2025

Dear ATO Community,


How are you? Rental property's Hot water System Gas broken down recently and leaked so we had to replace a brand new one (also gas, similar model).


Search through ATO Community re this is it treated as Immediate deduction (repair/maintenance) or need to be depreciated over 12 years?


There are 2 different answers from experts we can find in ATO community :


https://community.ato.gov.au/s/question/a0J9s000000NJiYEAW/p00190392?referrer=a0N9s000000DacEEAS


New HWS = depreciation item


Reason for change generally not relevant.


Then another one :


https://community.ato.gov.au/s/question/a0JRF000001jKmn/p00307338


In this case you can consider it a repair and make a claim in full.

Exactly like you said, you can't leave the tenants with cold water. I reckon they'll be especially wanting hot water in this cold winter. Well, it's rather chilly where I am.


If you'd made upgrades like installing solar to the hot water system, that'd be different.

You needed to keep the property in a tenantable condition, so this is a claim you can make now.


So a bit confused....which one is correct?

636 views
5 replies
636 views
5 replies

Most helpful response

All replies

Taxduck(Taxicorn)Taxicorn
28 Aug 2025

Be acquainted with the tax ruling on repairs. You will then know how they should be treated.

TR 97/23 | Legal database

Every landlord should have a thorough understanding of this.

You are replacing an entirety.(see paragraph 37). This is a capital repair. (i.e a depreciating asset)

Theresa(Champion)Registered Tax Professional
7 Sept 2025

The ATO’s guidance in TR 97/23 – Income tax: deductions for repairs and in their Rental properties guide is pretty clear:


If you replace an entire asset, that’s capital (depreciation).


If you only repair or replace part of it, that’s deductible immediately.


So, replacing a whole hot water system → new asset → ddepreciated

Loading
Would I claim broken down hot water system that was replaced as an immediate deduction or depreciation? | ATO Community