Loading
RandomTandem(I'm new)I'm new
9 Feb 2026

Negative gearing question below with **


Background: I am disabled and can only work about 20hours per week and am recently unemployed again. On the positive side, I was recently given one of my mother's houses. I do not need a whole 3-bedroom house to myself, and it has room in the back yard for a granny flat or even the front yard to do an extension on my garage and turn it into a separate living space. After getting a couple of rough quotes it looks like I would need to borrow 150-200k to build either option and it'll take about 6 months. With or without work I won't make enough to pay the loan so I would need to borrow enough to pay it for the first 6 months while the build is happening, so a small part of the loan won't be for the new building (about 10k) and I need a new used car to replace my 30 year old bomb, so another 5k for that would be handy while I am borrowing money.


**My main question is: will I be able to claim negative gearing or any type of tax deductions for taking a loan out on my house with the main purpose to rent the house out, even though I will still live on the property in a granny flat or extension? Would it matter if its either one? For example, you can claim tax if you live in the granny flat but not if you live in the house which would be the case in an extension, or vice versa?


Reasoning: Apparently, I can get at least $800 per week to rent out my house so my plan would be to take advantage of that and get off Centrelink which currently gives me about 800/fortnight, which I can now live off that I own a home - but only just. Renting my house out leaves me with 3200/month and I can live off half of that, so the other half (1600/month) can go to paying off the loan (without tax). AI says tax would be about 3,000 a year or 250/month leaving me with 1350/month to pay off the loan, and increasing it by 3-5years. I am worried it won't be worth it because of the extra tax on the income plus higher rates and other expenses involved with having renters. Ideally, I will find a job eventually and be able to pay the loan off faster but that could be 6-12months+ from now. I will have the house to myself in June and I just want to get things moving now if I can because it takes a good 6months to build.

274 views
4 replies
274 views
4 replies

Most helpful response

Most helpful reply

RachelATO(Community Moderator)Community Moderator
9 Feb 2026

Hi @RandomTandem,


Whether you can claim deductions for rental property expenses depends on how you use the property. If you rent out the main house and live in a granny flat or extension on the same property, you can generally claim deductions for expenses related to the rented portion. This includes interest on money borrowed to build or purchase the rental part of the property.


The rental income you receive is assessable income that you must declare on your tax return. You can claim deductions for expenses associated with earning that rental income, but you need to apportion these expenses correctly. You can only claim the portion of expenses that relates to the part of the property that's rented out and available for rent.


It doesn't matter whether you live in the granny flat and rent the house or live in an extension and rent the house, the principle is the same. You declare the rental income and claim deductions only for the expenses relating to the rented portion.


Keep in mind that renting out part of your property means you won't be entitled to the full main residence exemption from capital gains tax when you sell. You'll need to pay CGT on the portion that was rented out.


For the parts of your loan used for other purposes (like the $10,000 for loan repayments during construction or $5,000 for a car), you can't claim deductions for interest on those amounts because they're not used to earn rental income.


You'll need to read our rental properties guide to understand how to apportion your expenses correctly and what records to keep. We also have information about renting out all or part of your home that covers the key points for your tax return.

All replies

Most helpful reply

RachelATO(Community Moderator)Community Moderator
9 Feb 2026

Hi @RandomTandem,


Whether you can claim deductions for rental property expenses depends on how you use the property. If you rent out the main house and live in a granny flat or extension on the same property, you can generally claim deductions for expenses related to the rented portion. This includes interest on money borrowed to build or purchase the rental part of the property.


The rental income you receive is assessable income that you must declare on your tax return. You can claim deductions for expenses associated with earning that rental income, but you need to apportion these expenses correctly. You can only claim the portion of expenses that relates to the part of the property that's rented out and available for rent.


It doesn't matter whether you live in the granny flat and rent the house or live in an extension and rent the house, the principle is the same. You declare the rental income and claim deductions only for the expenses relating to the rented portion.


Keep in mind that renting out part of your property means you won't be entitled to the full main residence exemption from capital gains tax when you sell. You'll need to pay CGT on the portion that was rented out.


For the parts of your loan used for other purposes (like the $10,000 for loan repayments during construction or $5,000 for a car), you can't claim deductions for interest on those amounts because they're not used to earn rental income.


You'll need to read our rental properties guide to understand how to apportion your expenses correctly and what records to keep. We also have information about renting out all or part of your home that covers the key points for your tax return.

JenniferATO(Community Director)Community Director
9 Feb 2026

@RachelATO has given you some great info. Weighing in with an extra two cents.


When it comes to the financial side, I can see you've started some calculations. If you need, a licensed professional - like a financial adviser or planner - could help you weigh up the options based on your specific circumstances. Yes, there'd be a cost involved. But, they can walk you through the numbers, outline the potential risks and benefits, and support you in deciding what's right for you.

RandomTandem(I'm new)I'm new
10 Feb 2026

Thank you for your very detailed answer! I really appreciate it :)

I have no plans to sell this house anytime soon so I'm not too worried about the CGT. I am curious though. Considering I was gifted the property, and I paid over 20k stamp duty and transfer fees on it's 800k valuation, do you know if the CGT will be on the value gains after 800k?

My future plans/goals are to eventually rent the whole property out once the loan is paid off for the granny-flat or extension. I don't want to live in a granny flat or extension forever and I don't like my area anymore. I plan to move and buy a cheaper house in Gladstone or surrounding areas, and I'll use the $1000+ of weekly passive income to live and pay the future house mortgage. My friend recently bought a bigger and nicer house than mine for 400k in Gladstone (on twice the land too), so I would eventually like to do something similar to him and move away from the overcrowded and expensive Gold Coast.


You mentioned I would be able to claim expenses related to the rented portion, but I need the loan to build a place for me to live so I can rent the house out. Does this mean I can't claim any deductions because I will be taking a loan out to build the extension or granny flat for me to live in? Technically I need a place to live while I rent my house out so it is expenses related to me earning the income, just not directly. Its my understanding by your statement that I won't be able to claim expenses on the loan because it wasn't used for the rented part of the property? Is that right?

NikkiATO(Community Moderator)Community Moderator
10 Feb 2026

Hi @RandomTandem,


For CGT, when a property is received as a gift, the cost base is generally the market value at the time of transfer, plus incidental costs such as stamp duty and transfer fees. Your future capital gain is worked out from the sale price minus that cost base.


As mentioned earlier, interest is only deductible to the extent the borrowing is used for the income‑producing part of the property. If part of the loan is used to build the granny flat or extension you’ll live in, that portion is private and not deductible. Only the part used to build or improve the rented dwelling can be claimed, and all expenses must be apportioned between rented and private areas.

Loading
Can I do negative gearing on a home equity loan? | ATO Community