Loading
LiamPriceHSW(Initiate)Initiate
21 Feb 2024

Hi Brains Trust,


Looking for some guidance on a situation with a current client - I am a Financial Adviser.


Note: using simple rounded numbers for ease.


Date 1/1/2024

Client is 63 & working, currently has a TTR in place for $500,000 & Super balance of $100,000.

Pension Payments: YTD 1 July - 31 Dec paid $20,000 (Annual $40,000 max 10%).

Based on TTR 1 July 2023 Balance of $400,000.


Scenario: Client has renovation work coming up and wants to withdraw maximum funds to cover cost.

1/1/2024 Current TTR balance $500,000

1/1/2024 Current Super balance $100,000

1/1/2024 Total balance $600,000.


I have been advised by the Super fund that they will allow for a 10% withdrawal if a new TTR is commenced with the combined funds = $60,000. This means that the client would take $80,000 for FY24.


The Super fund has however advised that "generally it’s been understood advisers don’t follow this strategy as standard 1 of the code of ethics requirement to comply with the spirit of the law….which is one 10% withdrawal per annum."


Can I get some guidance from the ATO?


If this is 'not in the spirit' then how much is the client allowed to take to comply?



4,061 views
5 replies
4,061 views
5 replies

All replies

Bruce4Tax(Taxicorn)Taxicorn
21 Feb 2024

Not against the letter of the law, but could be against super fund's own rules - certainly looks like a breach of sole purpose.


One fix would be to roll to another super fund.


Your advice would need to consider the "best interest of client" rule - not just what client wants.



Loading
Restarting Transition to Retirement, max 10% withdrawal Twice | ATO Community