Okay, so I enabled myGovID on my myGov account with a Strong security strength.
I also disabled password authentication.
I have also setup Passkeys which is a new feature.
I can login to myGov using Passkeys and/or Digital ID (myGovID) and I can login to ATO. I haven't tested with the old password based authentication and 2FA since it has been disabled, but I'll agree with you and say that ATO cannot be accessed this way.
However, I was able to create a new MyGov account without any details except linking to a mobile number, and then I was able to link to the ATO account using two "secrets" known between myself and ATO. This means my ATO login is susceptible to "overlinking".
According to ATO website on myGov login it says this:
When you use your myGovID to sign in to myGov and link or access ATO online services, your highest identity strength becomes your online access strength. You'll use this for all future access to ATO online services.
For example, if you have a myGovID with a Strong identity strength and use it to sign in, your minimum online access strength will be Strong. Whenever you sign in to myGov to access ATO online services, you’ll need to use your Strong myGovID.
Your online access strength only applies to ATO online services. It doesn't apply to your myGov account or other linked myGov services.
This is confusing to me. I thought this might mean that once you have a myGovID of Strong, it means the only way to login to ATO is with a Strong access strength. However, I was able to "overlink" to ATO with a separate myGov account that was not linked to a Digital ID.
Therefore, myGovID might be a good protection for the myGov account providing better security from a potential password access compromise, but it doesn't prevent "overlinking".
Given what's at stake financially, ATO needs to provide better protections against fraudulent overlinking. I'm okay with a solution where a Digital ID must be linked to the myGov account with a minimum strength level to access ATO, regardless of what myGov account is used.