Loading
28 June 2025

We are starting a new school in NSW with ACNC charity status and ATO FBT rebate status.

I am trying to work out whether paying some salary as a Fringe Benefits is useful. I know it is for staff... but it seems to cost us significantly... and cost more overall than if staff paid income tax due to being taxed at the highest level (47%).


I've used this ATO page to work an example below but need to check I'm on track.


We have $150,000 allocated in our budget for Fringe Benefits.


My understanding is that staff do not pay individual income tax on these benefits. Is that correct?


e.g. staff receives $97,000 (salary - taxed) + Fringe Benefit ($30,000 - not taxed) 


Then, we calculate our FBT rebate. Imagining we pay individuals up to the max $30,000 cap in Type 2 benefits (GST-exempt benefits for simplicity here).


Type 2 Aggregate amount

= $150,000 (FBT paid) * 1.8868 (Type 2 aggregate)

= $283,020


Gross FBT Tax 

= $283,020*47%

= $133,091.40


FBT Rebate

= $133,091.40*47%

= $62,519.12


We pay expenses of $150,000 in benefits to staff.

We pay ATO $70,527 in FBT.


Question 1. It costs us an additional $70,527 to offer $150,000 of Fringe Benefits. This feels odd and like I'm missing something. If we paid income tax we could include $220,000 as an expense.

But we don't have an income tax bill to reduce - as charities are exempt from this tax.


Question 2: What is the justification of the 'gross-up' amounts? What does it reflect or represent? Is it just a deterant for companies to pay Fringe Benefits? It also doesn't make sense to me.


Thanks for any help!

236 views
1 replies
236 views
1 replies

Most helpful response

Most helpful replyATO Certified Response

DamienATO(Community Support)Community Support
ATO Certified Response1 July 2025

Hi @Green_Mountain,

 

FBT can get a bit mathy but you are definitely on the right track. We've also got a FBT calculator that can help give an estimate.

 

Question 1. Offering FBT can sometimes cost your school more than just paying the employee's salary. Even if you are eligible for the FBT rebate, it is capped at $30,000 per employee. Anything above this amount, you are required to pay the full FBT with no rebate.

 

This is why offering $150,000 in FBT can cost you $70,527 (after the rebate), as the rebate does not fully offset the FBT amount. As your school is income tax exempt, you don't get the usual tax deduction benefit a for-profit business would. If you want to read up further, we have our FBT - Guide for employers.

 

Question 2. The gross-up rate is designed to be comparable to the pre-tax amount for the benefit. It isn't a deterrent, but it does ensure benefits aren't more tax-effective than salary.

All replies

Most helpful replyATO Certified Response

DamienATO(Community Support)Community Support
ATO Certified Response1 July 2025

Hi @Green_Mountain,

 

FBT can get a bit mathy but you are definitely on the right track. We've also got a FBT calculator that can help give an estimate.

 

Question 1. Offering FBT can sometimes cost your school more than just paying the employee's salary. Even if you are eligible for the FBT rebate, it is capped at $30,000 per employee. Anything above this amount, you are required to pay the full FBT with no rebate.

 

This is why offering $150,000 in FBT can cost you $70,527 (after the rebate), as the rebate does not fully offset the FBT amount. As your school is income tax exempt, you don't get the usual tax deduction benefit a for-profit business would. If you want to read up further, we have our FBT - Guide for employers.

 

Question 2. The gross-up rate is designed to be comparable to the pre-tax amount for the benefit. It isn't a deterrent, but it does ensure benefits aren't more tax-effective than salary.

Loading
How does Fringe Benefit help a charity? | ATO Community