Loading
This thread is archived and the information may not be up-to-date. You can't reply to this thread.
ToPaMa(I'm new)I'm new
20 Jan 2022

I am trading shares and Crypto currencies on the popular online trading platform eToro, which used to offer only crypto currencies as CFDs. It has now commenced selling the actual underlying crypto assets instead, and has recently decided to impose overnight fees on the CFD positions if you dont convert them to underlying assets, and they have requested that I do so before 27 Jan. To convert them from CFD to underlying asset you have to first close the CFD position and then buy the underlying asset, and if done so within a ten-minute window, they will reimburse the spread fee.

 

Unfortunately, my CFD positions are currently at a loss

and thus closing them will result in me losing money, however as the cost of

buying the underlying crypto asset is lower, buying back the asset at the lower

price would evidently be proportionate thus with the spread reimbursed the

number of units would be the same and I would not be at a further loss (example

below). Would this constitute a wash sale?

 

To exemplify:

If when I invested $1000 in a Bitcoin CFD the price per unit was $2, I would acquire 500 units. If the price however now is $1 per unit, my 500 unit position would be valued at $500 thus I am at a loss of $500. If I was to convert this CFD to underlying Crypto asset by closing the CFD I would receive $500 from the position closure, and then would buy $500 worth of the actual asset which at $1 per unit would grant me the same number of units as I originally purchased, 500.

1,084 views
1 replies
1,084 views
1 replies

Most helpful response

Most helpful reply

RichATO(Community Support)Community Support
22 Jan 2022

Hello @ToPaMa


Welcome to the risks of CFD trading!

No, this scenario would not be treated or regarded as a wash sale. This is due to the differences in the investments before and after. They are not 'substantially identical".


The tax treatment of your case is:


  1. CFDs are on the revenue or income account. They are not subject to CGT. So your $500 loss on the closure of the BTC CFD position can be claimed as a deduction. The $500 you'll receive from the platform though is assessable income which must also be declared. Net effect on assessable income is $0.
  2. Your purchase of $500 of BTC is your cost base for a future capital gain or loss when you dispose of the cryptocurrency in the future.

All replies

Most helpful reply

RichATO(Community Support)Community Support
22 Jan 2022

Hello @ToPaMa


Welcome to the risks of CFD trading!

No, this scenario would not be treated or regarded as a wash sale. This is due to the differences in the investments before and after. They are not 'substantially identical".


The tax treatment of your case is:


  1. CFDs are on the revenue or income account. They are not subject to CGT. So your $500 loss on the closure of the BTC CFD position can be claimed as a deduction. The $500 you'll receive from the platform though is assessable income which must also be declared. Net effect on assessable income is $0.
  2. Your purchase of $500 of BTC is your cost base for a future capital gain or loss when you dispose of the cryptocurrency in the future.

Loading
Wash sale? | ATO Community